Web Page Design The Anatomy of High-Performing Web Pages
Kara McCain Nielsen Norman Group
Usability Week 2012
Instructor Kara McCain is a User Experience Specialist with Nielsen Norman Group. For more than 15 years, she has been creating innovative brand and user experiences in the search, social media, luxury, hotel, travel, jewelry, telecommunications, professional sports, ecommerce, government, and food-service industries. Her expertise has allowed her to develop and implement highly successful web and print design strategies for Fortune 500 companies. Before joining Nielsen Norman Group, McCain was a senior visual and interaction designer for Yahoo!'s Search and Social Media division, working on Yahoo! Answers, Local search, and defining the way people integrate social media into search. Prior to Yahoo!, she also led the Web design effort for clients such as Verizon, Pizza Hut, The Ritz-Carlton hotels, the Dallas Stars, Radio City Entertainment and the Zale Diamond Corporation. McCain holds a B.A. in Graphic Design from Abilene Christian University.
Conference Hashtag: #nnguw Follow me
@karacita1
2
Icons you will encounter in this seminar:
This is a good idea, or website implemented this idea well
This is a bad idea, don t do this; or the website did not implement this well
Keep in mind or Remember to do this
Tips to help you
Dangerous idea, do not implement–you re asking for trouble…
This will guarantee failure and/or your users will hate you. AVOID.
3
How Users Approach Web Pages Scanning, eye-tracking, scrolling & the fold
4
If you begin every new design (or redesign) with the common behaviors of users in mind, it will make design decisions a lot easier. Generally, people move through a page relatively quickly, faster than most of us would prefer. It’s only in certain cases that a person is willing to spend more of their precious time and attention on a site.
5
Scanning vs. a Thorough Review On the Web, users are impatient with short attention spans…they only spend an average of 27 seconds on a page. They don’t read much, they scan, seeking information quickly. So how you communicate (and allow users to communicate with you) matters. Q: So when do they actually read? A: When it s content they’re interested in (i.e. news story)
6
Scanning vs. a Thorough Review What do users pay attention to? • Headlines
(usually the first several words) • Subheadings • Bold/emphasized text • Short, important paragraphs • Lists What do they ignore? • Intro/marketing/welcoming
copy • Long or heavy paragraphs of text • Irrelevant images 7
www.turningpointlv.org
8
Little hierarchy makes it difficult to scan around for important information – everything has nearly equal weight, demanding equal attention
www.socialsecurity.gov
9
Headlines are bold, larger than body copy & easy to scan
Short paragraphs are easy to read quickly
www.latimes.com
10
Where Users Look – The Eyetracking Evidence F-Pattern of reading: The way users scan a page with little content hierarchy, in the shape of a letter F (sometimes E). More attention is paid to: • Words at beginning of line than the end • Words toward the top of text section
(vs. middle or bottom)
11
Where Users Look – the Eyetracking Evidence
F-pattern scanning!
12
Scrolling and the Fold It’s 2012. There is no one (or two) strictly defined “fold” anymore. The fold existed when virtually everyone had a 640 x 480 (or even a 1024 x 768) monitor. Now people access websites from all kinds of devices–with varying viewports–and you can’t always predict which one they will use to access your site.
1997: 640 x 480
2012: It could be anything! 13
Scrolling and the Fold But there is an ever-present “fold” on every device–it just depends on the screen size & mode the user is in. The area on a page that is viewable on the screen without having to manipulate the page by scrolling/using arrow keys (usually referred to in the vertical sense) is your fold. Design with that in mind. People spend 80% of their attention in that area. Do users scroll? Yes, but they only spend 20% of their time looking at information below the fold.
14
80% of attention 20% of attention
www.nytimes.com
Realistically, users read about 20% of the text on an average page
15
--------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------
Main navigation is right above the fold If you click a main nav button, content shows up here (below the fold, where user may not ever see it).
www.zennaware.com
16
What about long articles?
Article broken into multiple page views
VS. Single canvas with scrolling www.mayoclinic.com
17
Scrolling beats paging It’s easier for users to keep scrolling rather than decide if they want to click through various pages, foraging for information. If you choose a single canvas, you still must prioritize information and implement good hierarchy.
www.mayoclinic.com
18
Horizontal Scrolling What about horizontal scrolling? First – note that people spend more than twice as much time looking at the left side of the page as they do the right Left side: 69% of time Right side: 30% Most attention between the 300-500 pixel markers On a 1024 x 768 screen only 1% was viewed past 1024 pixels (that s worse than below-the-vertical fold s 20%) So, keep the most important information on the left: between 1/3 and 1/2 way across the page) 19
Do not take control away from the user. Scrollbar has been disabled, so user must use arrow keys (unless on iPad or touchscreen phone) to scroll or move around on the site
(default viewport)
www.yourauxiliary.com
(entire canvas)
20
Right-to-Left Languages What about languages that read right to left? More attention paid to the beginning of the line…the right side of the text It’s not a mirror image, though, unless the layout of a site mirrors the left-to-right layout.
21
True right-to-left layout
Mixed layout, but with right-to-left reading
www.emaratalyoum.com
www.haaretz.co.il 22
So if you add it all up…
300-500 pixels 80% of attention up here
Your most important content should lie within this area
www.nytimes.com
20% of attention down here
23
Other things to note • Users will fixate on an item that is interesting, even if it’s far
below the fold. It helps if the layout is designed to encourage scanning. • The last element in a list often attracts more attention ! the last
thing a person sees stays in the mind (the recency effect ). Put something good there! • Intensity in viewing degrades the farther the user scrolls !
dependent on motivation and interest
24
Remember this little guy? If you have long pages with a lot of content, it’s nice to provide users with a quick way to jump back to the top of the page if they’d like.
www.thefancy.com
Bagcheck.com/mobile
25
Remember Design for scanning behavior • Most important information at the top of the page • Group related sections of content together • Use descriptive headlines/subheadings • Use bullets for lists • Only use images that are relevant
Design for scrolling behavior • 80/20 attention range • Most important info on the left • No horizontal scrolling • Consider leaving long content on 1 page rather than paginating • Consider adding a “Back to Top” link for long pages 26
Working with Visuals & Typography How to guide users’ attention to the important stuff
27
Rules of Typography: General Some conventions from print also apply to the Web • Legibility and contrast
If people can’t see it, they can’t read it • Usage and number of fonts
Decide which font is truly appropriate; try to stick to two fonts (three max) • Usage of serif & san-serif
Use one for headlines, the other for body copy • Leading and kerning
Spacing between letters, spacing between lines of text • Hierarchy, grid & scale
Balance between sizes of fonts, images & eye rest
28
Rules of Typography: Web • USING ALL CAPS (except for headlines) THIS IS CONSIDERED SHOUTING! Please don’t " • Font Stacks If custom font can’t display, back-up safety fonts step in • Pixels, ems & percentages Fonts need ability to scale up or down…points can’t do this! • Color differences Dependent on monitor resolution & quality ! test on multiple machines • Text inside images ! if used for information, bad idea You can’t select it (to copy/paste) and screen readers can’t read it
29
Typography – Font size • Points are absolute (which is why they aren’t good for Web) For most sites you want to use relative font sizes. Use %, smaller/bigger, or ems ems: do not have an absolute size–they size themselves based on where they reside (i.e. the browser), so if the default browser font size is 16 px., then 1 em = 16 px. ; also relative to parent element’s font size %: Percentages are relative to another value (such as the width of a containing block) Smaller/bigger: relative to the default browser size and parent element’s font size
• Be nice – keep font sizes above 10 pt type 14-16 pt type is best for readability • Check your page’s type at 90%, 125% or higher See if type overflows and breaks the container space. Use CSS to control column widths/heights and font sizes. Remember, some users increase their font size via the browser/OS so plan for possible fluid containers. 30
2011: No hierarchy This site has lots of useful information but the typography (and layout & colors) make it difficult to scan or read
www.baking911.com, 2011
31
2012: Better! The layout has structure, better typography and a softer color palette.
www.baking911.com, 2012
32
Design for readability Main navigation is in tiny type that could be hard to read for most users
www.dailyexpress.co.uk
33
The main user goals & selling points are designed for prominence among the rest of the content
www.natureair.com
34
Highlight important & useful information Use typographic hierarchy to direct users attention. Tip: If you stand back from the page (or squint your eyes), the most important, relevant information should easily stand out.
www.everyblock.com
35
Typography – Font color A high-performance design requires good choice of font colors in addition to good typography. • No more than 4 colors (to avoid the rainbow effect) • Avoid dark backgrounds + bright text Unless it’s a headline or title, this is tough to read • Avoid color-on-color combinations that can’t be read • Red on blue • Yellow on red • Light on light • Dark on dark
Tip: De-saturate your website to black & white (or print it out in black & white) and look at the contrast. It should still be easy to read. If not, adjust the colors and repeat the process. 36
Gold text would be okay for a single headline…not okay for multiple lines of text, especially on a black background
www.bloomberg.com (old site, 2010)
37
Much better! • Text is easier to read • Headlines stand out from body copy • Cleaner overall
www.bloomberg.com (updated in spring 2011)
38
Extreme color contrast + bolding entire page makes reading painful
www.tacobell.com
39
Red-on-blue text is tough to read, even as a headline
www.houstontexans.com, 2011
40
Design for good color contrast between type and background
www.mariecatribs.com
www.lbdsociety.com
41
Using Images Effectively Users approach images in one of two ways Totally ignore them • Giant marketing photos • Pictures irrelevant to the content or subject • Stock photos (customer service lady on a headset)
- OR Fixate on & judge them • Product photos • Photos of real people (CEO of company, celebrities, etc)
42
Using Images Effectively On the Web, people only look at 42% of images presented to them. They look at those images for less than 2/10 of a second. Photos can give a person’s eyes rest from lots of text, but too many of them can add to a user’s cognitive load ! obstacle course behavior
43
Using Images Effectively Which ones get the most attention? • High quality, high contrast • Captivating, emotionally moving • Cropped for smaller space constraints (not squashed to fit) • Easy to understand • Highly relevant • Smiling, happy people; people facing the camera • Sexual in nature • Appetizing food
44
Images are highly relevant to content and help tell the story
www.bbc.co.uk
45
Photos that don’t match the headline/content may cause confusion or get ignored
www.bbc.co.uk
46
High quality, attractive product photos draw users in
www.teavana.com
47
Appetizing food + well-cropped photos
www.tastespotting.com
48
Black & white historical images need good, high contrast
www.sfcityguides.org
49
When people look happy, are smiling and looking at the camera, it catches the user’s attention
www.zappos.com
50
Using Images Ineffectively Which ones get the least attention? • Looks like an ad (even if it’s relevant to your content) • Too busy, too much going on • Irrelevant to content, used as a filler • Obvious stock photo, fake looking • Black & white photos that are too gray
(not enough contrast) • “Boring”
51
Image used as a filler, doesn’t help visualize parking options
www.nycballet.com
52
Hats are photographed from different distances, causing them to look like hats for children rather than women
www.bluefly.com
53
2011: Images are entirely too small to decipher
http://www.fedex.com/us/office/index.html
54
2012: A little better–images are larger and used more sparingly.
http://www.fedex.com/us/office/index.html
55
Mega Menus Organizing a large amount of navigation
56
Mega Menus Benefits: • Allows users to navigate larger portion of a web site in one
rollover, versus drilling down through multiple levels • Allows room for growth without compromising a site’s current structure or
design • Allows room for grouping links into categories to show
hierarchy • Illustrates a larger selection of choices
Misused when: • Menu is too long, user has to roll off to scroll (thus losing the menu
altogether) • Crowded with overwhelming amount of navigation 57
Menu is well-organized, in alphabetical order and makes use of highlighted rollovers
gatesfoundation.org
58
Pay attention to how the mega menu works against the area behind it
conservation.org
59
The ad (and the call-to-action button) in the mega menu competes with the ads/call-to-action behind it. A mega menu is not the place for ads)
staples.com
60
Not enough contrast between mega menu & main page so links run together
www.dell.com/us/p/
61
Keep the menu the Pay attention to howwell the above mega menu screen’s edge avoid users works against the to area behind it having to scroll to access lower menu items
www.whitehouse.gov
62
This multi-tasking mega menu houses real-time, at-a-glance data
www.reuters.com
63
Avoid overloading the mega menu Avoid increasing a user’s cognitive load…this makes it difficult to focus.
www.nih.gov
www.carnival.com
64
The mega menu’s photos add to the distinction between products without taking away from the task of navigating
www.steinway.com
65
The mega menu’s photos add to the distinction between products without taking away from the task of navigating
www.iwc.com
66
2011: Menu becomes seamless with the rest of the interface when open, BUT looks like a new page has opened
www.nbc.com, 2011
67
2012: Mega menu is slightly better, but still has issues
www.nbc.com, 2012
68
Paper & Pads is actually 20 listings of Paper, 11 listings of Pads and 13 additional listings ! NO FOCUS
www.staples.com
69
2011: mega menu for the site map was link overload
www.dell.com, 2011
2012: Better! Mega menu has digestible number of links, stays above screen’s edge, much cleaner www.dell.com, 2012
70
Can you spot all the design problems?
www.emc.com
71
This is a mega menu under a screen magnifier
www.whitehouse.gov mega menu
72
Mega Menus Pros: • Everything [in a section] is visible at once ! no scrolling • Links can be grouped in related sets to show hierarchical
relationships; icons, text sizes & colors can differentiate importance • Condenses main navigation into smaller chunks by [better] handling
sub-navigation
73
Mega Menus Cons: • Low-vision users who rely on screen-magnifiers might only see a
portion of the menu. • Touch-screen devices lack hover capability, so on-rollover/on-rolloff
activation does not work • Zoom-capable mobile devices might only show a portion of the menu • Mobile users (without zoom-capability) might see a cut-off version of
the menu • Doesn’t work if JavaScript or CSS is turned off
(only main nav button shows)
74
Mega Menus When to use: • Your site has a great deal of navigation and content
When not to use: • Mobile version of your site • Majority of your users will be using screen readers to view your site
75
Mega Menus: Working on the timing Our general rule of thumb: • User’s mouse should remain stationary for 0.5 seconds before
displaying anything hover-dependent • Interface elements must render within 0.1 seconds to show users
action has been taken • After user rolls their mouse off, wait 0.5 seconds before allowing menu
to disappear (except when pointer moves to another destination inside the menu) • Menu must then disappear within 0.1 seconds • Test response time on different computers/browsers
76
Remember Guidelines for using mega menu: • Menu • List
activates via on-rollover
links vertically (maximum 5-7 per column)
• Group
categories together when appropriate, bold category name
• Either
alphabetize links or order them according to most needed
• Do
not allow menu to go beyond the fold
• Consider • Clearly
context of how menu looks over entire page
show which section user is in
• Highlight
rollovers 77
Functional Footers Utilizing the end of a page, better than ever!
78
Functional Footers Not just a hall closet for your legal obligations! (and that one link you forgot to add in the wireframe)
Footers of the past: • The home for legal links (Privacy Policy, Copyright, etc.) • Used teeny, tiny text • Placed at the very bottom of the page where (hopefully) no one noticed it
Not sure where to put that not-really-important-but-still-required link? Violà! Put it in the footer!
79
Functional Footers Footers of today The valuable bottom-most real estate has useful information to help users move throughout the site and complete tasks more efficiently. These links also improve Search Engine Optimization (SEO). These extra links can help search engines (and people) find your content more easily (if links aren’t also in main navigation). Visually, many designers are giving the footer as much visual prominence as the header.
80
CNBC repeats their main navigation, only with subnavigation opened up in the footer
www.cnbc.com
81
Footer’s breadcrumb navigation shows path hierarchy
Footer relates to main section (in this case, “Mac”) www.apple.com
82
Visual treatment to divide footer from rest of the page Social calls-to-action
GOOD IDEA: Contact information is expanded (rather than just a “contact us” link) www.traveltex.com
83
Navigation within section Links to other sections user is in currently
finance.yahoo.com
Most popular links inside section
84
If your site has a large amount of content to navigate through, having a search box in the footer can be helpful
foodnetwork.com
85
Visual style of footer maintains continuity with the header and overall design concept Header = above ground Footer = below ground
floridaflourish.com
86
Remember Guidelines for implementing functional footers: • List
links vertically (maximum 5-7 per column)
• Group
categories together when appropriate, bold category name
• Either
alphabetize links or order them according to most needed
• Consider
adding a search box if appropriate
• Breadcrumb • If
trail should show where page lies in hierarchy of site
possible, expand contact information rather than making a link
• Make
footer unique to the audience/purpose
87
Designing on a Grid Implementing structure to the content
88
The Grid-Based Layout: a Tool, Not a Rule What it is Roots from print design, a layout based on a defined number of columns & rows spaced at regular intervals ! creating order out of chaos.
How it’s created Mathematical ratios of columns, rows and gutters are created to ensure consistency, that the typography scales well and content is easily read. Columns are [groupings of grid units] used to align page elements. Gutters are the spaces between the columns ! same width throughout the layout. Note: Content’s typography should be addressed before implementing a grid-based layout. Do not adjust type size for the sake of fitting content inside a grid.
89
Why a Grid-Based Layout Works • Creates an orderly framework for designer/developer, can even make
the design/development process faster • Gives website structure, consistency & logic for users • Lots of layout options, many different kinds of grids
Myth: Following a grid restricts creativity Fact: Music, language and architecture all have order/rules but that does not stop the output from being diverse and beautiful A grid is not meant to define a design, it’s meant to work with the design… your design does not have to look grid-like.
90
Columns (thick dark areas)
BBC s website based on a grid
Gutters (thin light areas)
91
9 Columns, 10 Gutters
www.waterworks.com
92
www.thegridsystem.org
93
Tips for a Grid-Based Layout Before working with a grid: • Address content/typography & image issues first Do not adjust fonts & type size or shrink/expand images in order to force content into a grid
• Determine the constraints of the project • Advertising accommodations • Device(s) website needs to work on • CSS framework being used ! check the default dimensions of framework
Pixels are your base unit of measurement • Use increments of pixels, not individual pixels • Increments of 10 px is a good start (but not a rule, of course)
Align page elements to columns Think of columns as guides 94
Integrating Music, Video & other Multimedia Elements When it’s appropriate and how it should work
95
Aside from avoiding automatically playing music, make volume controls easy to find
www.fergie.com
96
Allow the user to choose when to play something
ge.com
97
Use correct, standardized icons for players
clickmix.com
98
Use correct state for icons
johnnyrockets.com
Music is actually not on
99
If showing advertisements, show how long ad will be
cnn.com
100
Avoid using technical terms only some users will understand (unless you are targeting video/audio professionals)
hulu.com
101
• Avoid using tiny icons for
file types & be clear about what icon represents
• Offer more than one
format so user can select the one they want
investors.yum.com
102
Displaying Videos in Search Results On a general search results page: Thumbnails are on right side of results because they are complementary to the query focus
yahoo.com
103
Displaying Videos in Search Results On video-only search results page Thumbnails are displayed in a gallery rather than a list to maximize space
yahoo.com
If user clicks play button, video plays at top rather than opening a new window or going to another page
Video name Length Date Source 104
Integrating Other Multimedia Elements Make sure multimedia addresses the design problem you are trying to solve. Sometimes it can enhance an experience, other times it can become over designed and make it worse. Know your audience, their needs and technical knowledge base.
105
World of Warcraft’s audience is very tech savvy but the website chooses to keep instructions and interactivity simple Simple rollovers help explain game mechanics to new players
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/game/guide/getting-started
106
Entire website is exploratory so finding basic information about jeans is difficult. Product images are not helpful.
http://www.mediaboom.com/prospectdenim/
107
Alternate product views are available and simple to use
www.zappos.com
108
Multimedia overkill
Important information is hard to read in small text box Scroll bar has also been redesigned so not as noticable
www.gotmilk.com
109
Information is easy to find and read; animations are kept to a minimum and only activate on rollover
www.8thcontinent.com
110
Recap: Integrating Music & Video Do NOT auto-play (especially in a pop-up) • Allow users to decide when they want to play something; they might not want
to listen to it at all or are already listening to their own music • Consider users who have multiple browser tabs open (and have no idea
where music/audio is coming from ! irritating) • Consider users who might not be in an optimal place to project sound (work,
public place) • Music & video interferes with screen readers ! accessibility problem
Keep videos under 3-5 minutes • Break up longer videos into several digestible segments • Our data shows people’s interest tends to wane after 24 seconds
Choose files that are designed for your audience’s connection speed & device • Not everyone has broadband so content may load slowly 111
Recap: Integrating Music & Video Implement correct usage of music/video player controls • Avoid designing new & different ones–stick with convention (users see these
controls on lots of other sites besides yours)
When possible, host your own content (vs. putting it on YouTube) • You want to maintain strict control over your content & how it’s shared • If allowing comments, you should have them on your site where your audience will contribute vs. the larger YouTube audience
Avoid being too technical or too vague with options • Not everyone understands what 480p means (unless site is for specific audience)
If showing ad, display how long it will play/time left to play • Better to show ad after initial clip rather than before, if possible
Use text markup for accessibility and SEO 112
Within-Page Updates for Dynamic Pages How to use them & when to avoid them
113
Within-page updates give users timely information without having to reload the page or click to another page entirely, saving the user time and effort. Other Advantages • Information is stored in a database rather than being hardcoded into static HTML
pages, allowing for quicker updates • Better customization ! server can create a page based on user-input • Large sites do not have to build thousands of HTML files. Templates are used
instead and display custom information based on user input ! saves time and server space.
Disadvantages • Dynamic pages are not always indexed well by search engines • Bookmarking can be difficult because same resources might not exist next time
user visits the page • Some users will not have JavaScript enabled to see updates 114
Shopping cart dynamically updates when user adds a product to their cart. BONUS: User can calculate shipping costs inside the cart Note: user must notice even small changes that occur www.skincarerx.com
115
User can mouse over a product image to easily zoom in on product features
www.burton.co.uk
116
Instant feedback can be helpful to prevent user errors
www.twitter.com
117
User can manipulate layover duration, trip leg & price range via the slider bars
Good: Be specific about criteria being used
Rather than using $ $$$$ which is vague www.kayak.com
118
Give feedback to let users know content is updating
Changes should occur very close to where a user’s focus already is But be specific: The wording should reflects user’s filtering choice: “Filtering by price”
www.kayak.com
119
Map choices to user selections (and removal) when involving location
www.hotwire.com
120
Tips for Within-Page Updates Optimize pages for search engines • Keep the parameters short and few • Keep your URLs short • Use a [static] site map/site index to encourage deep indexing
Develop with progressive enhancement • Your site should look and work well in HTML ! add enhancements as a bonus so viewers of either get the information they need
Give feedback when content is updating based on user input • Specifically reflect user s parameter choice Use: Filtering by location Not: Fetching Results…
Don’t over notify users when content updates frequently • Ex: Flashing icon every time an email is received (bad when user receives many emails in a short period of time)
Response time should be fast • Ideally less than 0.1 seconds 121
When to Avoid Using Within-Page Updates If poor performance & caching issues hinder user experience If significant % of users are using screenreaders and/or screen magnifiers to view site • Screenreaders announce when a new page loads, not when new content within the page loads • Screen magnifiers only show portion of the page, which user might miss
If the feature doesn’t really support user need • If your site has few repeated actions, creating a complex GUI isn’t worth the time or money • A non-dynamic feature that works just as well or better should be used instead
If the user experience is not improved by using update • Test the features against a replicated page that doesn’t use them and evaluate success/failures
122
Advertising & User Behavior How people react to ads online
123
The worst thing you can do when advertising online is neglect the user experience
Fake dialogue box – Most hated #3
Measurements for traffic & click-through rates do not include user dissatisfaction or drop in credibility/opinion. Using correct design techniques can improve the impact of your ads and keep your credibility in tact. 124
Most-hated ad techniques (in order of disgust) 1. Popup ads ! associated with unsavory content 2. Ad loads slowly 3. Ads that look like system messages or real content with no clear distinction between the two ! unethical! 4. Does not have a close button 5. Covers what you are trying to see 6. Doesn’t say what it is for 7. Moves content around 8. Occupies most of page 9. Blinks on and off 10. Floats across the screen 11. Automatically plays sound 125
Disdain for ads has led to banner blindness. Q: But what if it’s not an ad, it’s real content? A: You’re still in trouble if it has: • Heavily formatted areas of text • Made up terms, branded descriptions, fancy marketing speak • Promotional copy or images + copy, even for your own information/products • Design elements that look like ads
In addition to banner blindness, bad advertising techniques • Create a poor user experience ! users lose trust • Degrade credibility/opinion of your site • Degrade credibility/opinion of your company (if it’s your ad on another site)
126
Specials or promotions that look like your average banner ads will most likely be ignored
www.schwans.com
127
If you want to promote your content on your site, design it to blend in with the rest of the site so users know it’s from your company
www.carnival.com
128
Banner takes up most of page
Irony: this is on an advertising news site, right above an article about good design
www. http://advertising-information.com.com
129
Video news: looks like ad
News report: looks like ad
Website poll: looks like ad
www.webmd.com
130
This is the equivalent of a pop-up ad, but worse…user has to close the modal dialog before accessing page
designtutorials4u.com
131
Designing for Evil: purposefully abusing UI behavior, knowing some (or many) users will mistaken the interaction for something else – like an important alert
Irony: the article under there is about annoying, intrusive ads bizreport.com
132
Q: Are there any successful ads? A: Yes! • Text-based ads on search engines (This could follow into the category of making ad look like content but it is content and many times is relevant, even if paid for…only most relevant ones will show up)
• Classified ads • Ads that: • Indicate what happens if clicked • Relates to user s activity online • Identifies itself as advertisement • Presents information about what is being advertised • Provides additional information without having to leave the page
Ads most effective at attracting user attention • Plain text • Faces • Cleavage/”private” body parts (sex sells) 133
Search ads are designed to look like the rest of search results page Why isn’t this designing for evil? Because the ads only display when they are truly relevant to the user’s query
www.google.com
134
Tips for Using Advertising Online Use ethical advertising practices • Don’t design for evil just because you know something works • Consider your long-term reputation
Speak plainly, make options clear, provide useful information Avoid pop-ups (and modal boxes that act like pop ups) Don’t accept ads on your site that 85% of the population hates If using other companies’ ads on your site, put them in the periphery of the page. If on the home page, they should be as small & discreet as possible.
Work with the medium Take mobile users into consideration. Many ads don’t cross over from desktop to mobile well, causing a bad experience. 135
Productive Use of the Twilight Zone Using the right-hand column to your advantage
136
What we know about horizontal attention • •
Users spend 69% of their time viewing the left side of the page They only spend 30% viewing the right side (remaining 1% is if they have to horizontally scroll…which they tend to avoid doing)
Study done on 1024 x 768 monitor
137
How to make use of this Twilight Zone of the page • Provide supplemental–not crucial–tools or information relevant to main content • Maintain consistency…once users learn where to look for tools/ information they will look there again and expect to find it • Area should be looked at as a place to enhance user experience ! you should be able to remove the elements on the right side of the page and still have a successful task completion
138
Relevant facets also containing results from user’s search query listed on right
www.flickr.com
139
Photo remains focus of page. Secondary attributes and features of photo are placed at the right Photo attribute: where photo was taken
Photo carousel: other photos from user Other places in site where photo appears
Photo attribute: tags associated with photo Privacy settings for photo (owner can toggle) www.flickr.com
140
Customers who purchased this item also purchased these items If item is new or there are no related items, informational (but not crucial) content moves up
www.zappos.com
141
Supplemental–but not critical– information on the right side
Users can quickly learn where tags and Related Questions live in the UI because they are consistently placed
http://ui.stackexchange.com/
142
Design Criteria for Special Purpose Pages Home • Category • Product • Gallery • SERP listings
143
Design Criteria: The Home Page The home page is the front door to your website and it gets more views than any other page. When users land on another page in your site from a search engine or deep link, one of the first places they go to is the home page.
Top Things to Improve Home Page • Don’t literally welcome” users to your site ! use a good tagline instead • Design the home page to look differently than all other pages (should still fit with
overall look-and-feel) • Make sure the search box is prominent
Top area of page is best (right or left) ! should be about 27-30 characters long • Avoid putting any top horizontal navigation (primary or otherwise) above graphical
treatments such as horizontal rules or banner areas ! might invoke banner blindness
144
Design Criteria: The Home Page Top Things to Improve Home Page (con’t) • Use graphics & photos to show real content ! label photos that aren’t
obvious in their relation of the story. • Edit photos and diagrams appropriately for the display size • Avoid animation on the home page ! too distracting, too many other things
competing for user’s attention • Do not force an animated intro on your users ! give them an option to skip
it (better yet, don’t use one) • Limit font styles to 2 (one serif, one san-serif)
145
Take the red pill or the blue pill?…
http://www.motorola.com/us
146
Allow room for white space – don’t fill every pixel on the page with content ! hard for users to focus
www.tigerdirect.com
147
Use photos of people that have a real connection to the content, not generic stock photos
www.telestream.net
148
Label people in the photo (even if they are ‘famous’) Also cite the source of the photo
www.espn.com
149
Don’t shrink down large images to fit a small space. Crop the photo and offer link to see larger version.
Way too small to read!
www.nycballet.com
150
If you offer a link to see a larger version of a map (or image) make sure it is, in fact, significantly larger…
www.goodsam.org
151
Avoid overlydecorative fonts Keep number of fonts to a minimum (1-2)
dollardreadful.com
152
Design Criteria: Category Pages Top Things to Improve Category Pages • Keep options to a comfortable minimum to avoid crowding the page and
overwhelming the user with choices • Be careful in how you display featured items ! it can look like those are
the only things you offer • Avoid designing navigational options look like product listings • Distinguish similar items from each other • Don’t automatically move users into a subcategory of products • Keep main categories to a minimum so users aren t overwhelmed with
choices
153
Avoid making navigational options look like product listings ! page can be confused with an actual product page
www.crateandbarrel.com
154
What are the differences between these televisions?
www.tigerdirect.com
155
Featured items look like only items available
www.staples.com
156
2011: Too much space devoted to descriptive or promotional images, rather than content
www.rei.com, 2011
2012: A little better… descriptive image is removed to elevate content www.rei.com, 2012
157
Design Criteria: Product Pages Top Things to Improve Product Pages • Use short, descriptive product names • List the most important information first in product names • Use high-quality and large/detailed enough images for products • Indicate if styles, colors or options other than those pictured are available • If different colors of the same product are listed as unique products, always
present the other color options on the product page • Show availability information on product listing pages • Clearly indicate how products are sorted • Provide a way to compare details of similar items ! show images w/details
158
Short product descriptions tell exactly what makes up each chocolate bar ! no marketing text
www.vosgeschocolate.com
159
Products are listed as individual items, even though it’s the same item in different colors
Product detail page focuses on chosen color while showing additional color options
www.zappos.com
160
Price + available size information are available on product listing page (on rollover), saving the user time
www.yoox.com
161
Design Criteria: Gallery Pages Top Things to Improve Gallery Pages • Use short, descriptive information for each image/video • If relevant, provide image/video size, date created/uploaded, length of time,
source • For video, choose thumbnail/static screen that clearly denotes what the video
is about ! avoid black screen with just a play button • Allow white space between images/videos to give eye rest and time to visually
process images • Let users choose to see a smaller number of larger images or a larger number
of smaller images
162
User can filter by image size, color, and black & white
images.yahoo.com
Image information isn’t available until user rolls over image
163
Thumbnails of videos are screenshots from each episode Episode title, season, episode number and length of clip are given
www.hulu.com
164
Design Criteria: Search Result Listings Top Things to Improve Search Result Listings • Mimic the search results layout of major search engines
(Google, Yahoo!, Bing) • If supplementing listing with a photo, place photo to the right of the result • If user does an image or video search • Many results – display as a gallery • One or few results – display the image/video first with text-based information to
the right
• If result is a document or article, display date it was written, type of
document (PDF, Word doc, etc.), and weight • Allow sorting for many results ! place sorting options close to results • If there are zero results, provide related query options (as links) to start a
new search ! do not tell them sorry, try again 165
The formula: Search result Title Display text (called the “abstract”) Page URL
People expect search results on your page to look and act like results from a major search engine
Yahoo! Search results
166
Prompt users to clarify a query if different types of results will show up
www.gettyimages.com
167
In Conclusion… Creating high performing pages involves applying solid design and usability principles at every stage of your site’s development. However, sometimes a tweak here and there can take your regular, “it’s not bad” page to one with higher conversions, happier users and higher profits. No matter what design elements you decide to implement, always test and re-test!
168
Thank you!
Need to contact me? e-mail:
[email protected]
169
References & Recommended Reading Designing on a Grid Showcase of grid-based designs www.designbygrid.com/showcase
YUI CSS Grid Builder http://developer.yahoo.com/yui/grids/builder/
GridFox Firefox plug-in http://www.puidokas.com/portfolio/gridfox/
Typogridphy – A Typographical & Grid Layout CSS Framework http://csswizardry.com/typogridphy/
The Gridulator – Plug in your numbers and get a grid! http://gridulator.com/
Blueprint CSS Framework http://www.blueprintcss.org/
Book: Ordering Disorder: Grid Principles for Web Design by Khoi Vinh
Responsive Layouts Book: Responsive Web Design by Ethan Marcotte Tutorial: http://www.slideshare.net/AaronGustafson/css-adaptive-layouts-with-media-queries 170
References & Recommended Reading Design Guidelines for Special Purpose Pages Book: Homepage Usability: 50 Websites Deconstructed by Jakob Nielsen & Marie Tahir Reports: E-commerce User Experience Report by Nielsen Norman Group http://www.nngroup.com/reports/ecommerce/
Designing for Various Platforms Report (free): Usability of iPad Apps and Websites by Nielsen Norman Group http://www.nngroup.com/reports/mobile/ipad/
Online Web Fonts Typekit // typekit.com Monotype Imaging //webfonts.fonts.com Fontshop www.fontshop.com
Designing for International Pages IBM s Guidelines to Design Global Solutions: http://www-01.ibm.com/software/globalization/guidelines/
171
! !
! Design Review Are you sure that your website needs help but unsure of why? Do you simply need a credible, outside confirmation of your assumptions? In either case, NN/g can help. In these Design Reviews we leverage the thousands of hours of live usability research our experts have completed to sniff out the usable and unusable elements of your design. Experts will assess the usability of your design — working, wireframe, or prototype — relative to current best practices.
! !
The written report we produce includes:
!
A Sample of Services Offered by Nielsen Norman Group Full information about these and more services at:
www.nngroup.com/services
! !
• • •
a prioritized list of findings the reasoning behind each finding, with examples recommendations for improvements.
Limitations: The design must be in English for us to be able to review it. For an intranet, you must provide us with remote access or give us the pages on CD-ROM or similar format that does not require live access.
Usability Studies NN/g experts have years of experience under their belts in testing not only websites, but intranets, software, mobile devices, and almost anything else that has a user interface. We will test your design, whatever it may be, with the right users, wherever they may be. (If your website markets to the United States but your organization is located elsewhere, we can run studies with American users without the usual extra travel costs of such tests.) NN/g can take care of everything, or help you with just phases of the testing. You decide. Intranets: Testing should be performed at your location. You provide the intranet users, and we can help you with user recruiting.
!
In-House Seminars
!
Any of the full-day seminars presented at this conference, plus various other keynote addresses, by Nielsen Norman Group members are available as in-house events. World-class usability experts come to you and evangelize usability, convert the doubters, and teach the interested. Bring the seminars you enjoyed at our conference back to your office. We can present the content as is to almost any size audience, or adapt the content to best meet your organization’s needs.
! !
3-Day Learning by Doing Workshop This well-received workshop is dual-purpose: Test your design while teaching your team how to conduct usability tests. In this three-day seminar our usability experts guide your team through a fast and simple approach to user testing. And using your design as the case study throughout three days is a very motivating way for your team to learn about usability. We will work with you to: • • • •
plan the study facilitate the sessions analyze the results report the results.
When the seminar is complete your team will have not only produced a usability report about your design, but they will have learned how to do usability tests on their own.
!