Labor Relations Cases: March 3, 2020 Recitation Of Cases

LABOR RELATIONS CASES

MARCH 3, 2020 RECITATION OF CASES 1. EMPLOYEE RECOGNITION: PANGILINAN VS GENERAL MILLING CORPORATION; GR NO. 149329, JULY 12, 2004 2. REGULAR EMPLOYEE-NATURE OF WORK: HACIENDA FATIMA VS NATIONAL FEDERATION OF SUGAR WORKERS FOOD AND GENERAL TRADE; GR NO. 149440, JANUARY 28, 2003 3. EXTENDED PERIOD: AUDION ELECTRIC CO, INC VS. NLRC AND NICOLAS MADOLID; GR NO. 106648, JUNE 17, 1999 4. REPEATED RENEWAL CONTRACT: MARAGUINOT, JR. AND PAULINO ENERO VS. NLRC, VIC DEL ROSARIO, VIVA FILMS; GR. NO. 120969, JANUARY 22, 1998 5. PROJECT EMPLOYEE: HANJIN HEAVY INDUSTRIES AND CONSTRUCTION CO, LTD. VS. FELICITO IBAÑEZ, ETAL; GR NO. 170181, JUNE 26, 2008 6. PROJECT EMPLOYEE: MACARTHUR MALICDEM AND HERMEINIGILDO FLORES VS.MARULAS INDUSTRIAL CORPORATION AND MIKE MANCILLA; GR. NO. 204406, FEBRUARY 26,2014 7. WORKPOOL EMPLOYEE: J.&D.O.AGUILAR CORPORATION VS. NLRC AND ROMEO ACEDILLO; GR. NO.116352, MARCH 13, 1997 8. CASUAL EMPLOYEE - NATURE OF WORK: A.M. ORETA AND CO., INC. VS. NLRC AND SIXTO GRULLA, JR.; GR NO. 74004, AUGUST 10, 1989 9. ONE YEAR SERVICE: INTEGRATED CONTRACTOR AND PLUMBING WORKS, INC., VS. NLRC AND GLEN SOLON; GR NO. 152427, AUGUST 9, 2005 10. FIXED TERM: LYNVIL FISHING ENTERPRISES, INC., AND ROSENDO S. DE BORJA VS. ANDRES G. ARIOLA, ETAL.; GR. NO. 181974, FEBRUARY 1, 2012 11. SEASONAL: HACIENDA BINO/HORTENCIA STARKE, INC/HORTENCIA L.STARKE; GR.NO. 150478, APRIL 15, 2005 12. PROBATIONARY: CEBU MARINE BEACH RESORT, ETAL. VS. NLRC, RIC RODRIGUEZ, ETAL., GR.NO. 143252; OCTOBER 23, 2003 13. EMPLOYER RIGHT TO SET PERIOD/ OBLIGATION: ORIENT EXPRESS PLACEMENT PHILIPPINES VS. NLRC,POEA AND ANTONIO FLORES; GR.NO. 113713, JUNE 11, 1997 14. DURATION - EXCEPTION: CANADIAN OPPORTUNITIES UNLIMITED, INC. VS. BART DALANGIN, JR.; GR. NO. 172223, FEBRUARY 6, 2012 15. CRITERIA REGULARIZATION: UNIVAC DEVELOPMENT VS. WILLIAM M. SORIANO; GR. NO. 182072, JUNE 19, 2013 16. EXTENSION OF CONTRACT: MARIWASA MANUFACTURING, INC., AND ANGEL T. DAZO VS. HON. VICENTE LEOGARDO, JR, AND JOAQUIN A. DEQUILA; GR. NO. 74246, JANUARY 26, 1989

MARCH 10, 2020 RECITATION OF CASES 17. ABSORBED EMPLOYEE: CEBU STEVEDORING CO. INC., THE HONORABLE REGIONAL DIRECTOR/MINISTER OF LABOR, ARSENIO GELIG AND MARIA LUZ QUIJANO; GR. NO. L-54285, DECEMBER 8, 1988

18. RULE ON PRIVATE SCHOOL TEACHERS: COLEGIO DEL SANTISIMO ROSARION AND SR. ZENAIDA S. MOFADA,OP VS. EMMANUEL ROJO; GR. NO. 170388, SEPTEMBER 4, 2013 19. TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT - SECURITY OF TENURE: NEGROS SLASHERS, INC., RODOLFO C. ALVAREZ AND VICENTE TAN VS. ALVIN L. TENG; GR. NO. 187122, FEBRUARY 22, 2012 20. GUIDELINES ON IMPOSITION OF PENALTY: VICENTE C. ECTUBAN, JR., VS. SULPICIO LINES, INC.; GR. NO. 148410, JANUARY 17, 2005 21. TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT - RESIGNATION: LAZARO V. DACUT, CESARIO CAJOTE, ETAL. VS. CA, STA CLARA INTERNATIONAL TRANSPORT AND EQUIPMENT CORPORATION, AND NICANDRO LINAO; GR.NO. 169434, MARCH 28, 2008 22. WITHOUT JUST CAUSE:MICHELLE TUAZON VS BANK OF COMMERCE , RAUL DE MESA AND MARIO PADILLA; GR.NO. 192076, NOVEMBER 21, 2012 23. BASIS FOR TERMINATION:NORMAN YABUT VS. MANILA ELECTRIC COMPANY AND MANUEL M . LOPEZ; G.R.NO. 190436, JANUARY 16, 2012 24. SUBSTANTIAL REQUIRMENTS - JUST CAUSES - SERIOUS MISCONDUCT/WILLFUL DISOBEDIENCE: NATHANIEL DONGON VS. RAPID MOVERS AND FORWARDERS CO.INC., AND NICANOR JAO; GR. NO. 163431, AUGUST 28, 2013 25. SUBSTANTIAL AND PROCEDURAL DUE PROCESS: METRO EYE SECURITY, INC., VS. JULIE SALSONA; GR.NO. 167637, SEPTEMBER 28, 2007 26. GROSS AND HABITUAL NEGLECT OF DUTIES: CNTURYIRON WORKS, INC., AND BENITO CHUA VS. ELETO BANAS; GR.NO. 184116, JUNE 19, 2013 27. FRAUD OR WILLFUL BREACH OF TRUST: ROLANDO TORRES VS. RURAL BANK OF SAN JUAN, INC., ANDRES CANO CHUA, ETAL; GR.NO. 184520, MARCH 13, 2013 28. COMMISSION OF CRIME: SAMPAGUITA GARMENTS CORPORATION VS. NLRC AND EMILIA SANTOS; GR. NO. 102406, JUNE 17, 1994 29. ANALOGOUS CASES: SAMPAGUITA AUTO TRANSPORT CORPORATION VS. NLRC AND EFREN SAGAD; GR NO. 197384, JANUARY 30, 2013 30. JUST CAUSES CLAIMED BY EMPOYER: TAN BROTHERS CORPORATION OF BASILAN CITY THROUGH MAURICIO TAN; GR.NO. 188711, JULY 8, 2013 31. COURTESY RESIGNATION: BIENVENIDO BATONGBACAL VS. ASSOCIATED BANK AND NLRC; GR.NO. 72977, DECEMBER 21, 1988 32. CHANGE OF OWNERSHIP:ELCEE FARMS, INC., AND CORAZON SAGUEMULLER VS. NLRC, ETAL.; GR.NO. 126428, JANUARY 25, 2007 33. HABITUAL ABSENTEEISM: MANILA ELECTRIC COMPANY VS. NLRC AND JEREMIAH CORTEZ; GR. NO. 114129’ OCTOBER 24, 1996 34. FIXED TERM EMPLOYMENT: RICARDO MEDENILLA, ETAL. VS. PHILIPPINE VETERNS BANK, RENAN SANTOS, PACIFICO CERVANTES, LOIS OLARTE; GR.NO. 127673, MARCH 13, 2000

MARCH 17, 2020 RECITATION OF CASES 35. PAST OFFENSES: CENTURY CANNING CORPORATION, RICARDO PO,JR AND AMANCIO RONQUILLO VS. VICENTE RANDY RAMIL; GR NO. 171630, AUGUST 8, 2010

36. IMMORALITY: JOSE SANTOS,JR. VS. NLRC, HAGONOY INSTITUTE INC , ETAL.; GR.NO. 115795, MARCH 6, 1998 37. CONSTRUCTIVE DISMISSAL: DUSIT HOTEL NIKKO AND PHILIPPINE HOTELIERS, INC. VS. NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS IN HOTEL, RESTAURANT AND ALLIED INDUSTRIES - DUSIT HOTEL NIKKO CHAPTER AND ROWENA AGONCILLO; GR.NO. 160391, AUGUST 9, 2005 38. TRANSFER/REASSIGNMENT OF WORK: BEST WEAR GARMENTS AND ARREN PARDILLA VS. ADELAIDA DE LEMOS AND CICILE OCUBILLO; GR. NO. 191281, DECEMBER 5, 2012 39. RESIDENCY TRAINING: ALFREDO FELIX VS. DR. BRIGIDA BUENASEDA,ETAL AND THE CIVIL SERVICE; GR. NO. 109704, JANUARY 17, 1995 40. BUSINESS RELATED - RETRENCHMENT: SANOH FULTON PHILIPPINES; INC, AND MR. EDDIE JOSE VS. EMMANUEL BERNARDO AND SAMUEL TAGHOY; GR NO. 187214, AUGUST 14, 2013 41. REDUNDANCY: SPI TECHNOLOGIES,INC. AND LEA VILLANUEVA VS. VICTORIA MAPUA; GR. NO. 191154, APRIL 7, 2014 42. TEMPORARY CLOSURE: SKM ART CRAFT CORPORATION VS. EFREN BAUCA ETAL.; GR.NO. 171282, NOVEMBER 27, 2013 43. CLOSURE OF BUSINESS: SANGWOO PHILIPPINES, INC, ETAL. VS. SANGWOO PHILIPPINES ,INC., EMPLOYEE UNION; GR. NO. 173154/GR NO. 173229, DECEMBER 9, 2013 44. DISEASE: CRAYONS PROCESSING, INC. VS. FELIPE PULA AND CA; GR. NO. 167727, JULY 30, 2007 45. ENFORCEMENT OF UNION SECURITY CLAUSE IN THE CBA: HEMINIGILDO INGUILLO AND ZENAIDA BERGANTE VS. FIRST PHILIPPINE SCALES AND AMPARO POLICARPIO; GR. NO. 165407, JUNE 5, 2009 46. PROCEDURAL REQUIREMENTS: JAKA FOOD PROCESSING CORPORATION GS. DARWIN PACOT, ETAL.; GR.NO. 151378, MARCH 28, 2005 47. HEARING: TECHNOL EIGHT PHILIPPINES CORPORATION VS. NLRC AND DENNIS AMULAR; GR. NO. 187605, APRIL 13, 2010 48. USE OF POSITION PAPER: SHOPPES MANILA, INC. VS.NLRC; GR. NO. 147125, JANUARY 14, 2004 49. DECISION: RUBEN ANDRADA VS. AGEMAR MANNING AGENCY, INC., AND SHIPPING MALTA; GR. NO. 194758, OCTOBER 24, 2012 50. APPEALS BOND: ANDREW JAMES MCBURNE VS. EULALIO GANZON, ETAL. ; GR.NO. 178034 AND 178117 AND GR NOS. 186984-85, OCOBER 17, 2013 51. QUITCLAIM: HYPTIE AUJERO VS. PHILIPPINE COMMUNICATIONS SATELLITE CORPORATION; GR. NO. 193484, JANUARY 18, 2012 52. PRESCRIPTION: UNIVERSITY OF THE EAST VS. UNIVERSITY OF THE EAST EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION; GR. NO. 179593, SEPTEMBER 14, 2011 53. CRIMINAL CASES: LOLITA S. CONCEPCION VS. MINEX IMPORT CORPORATION, ETA.;GR.NO. 153569, JANUARY 24, 2012

LONG QUIZ AND DEADLINE OF CASE DIGESTS: MARCH 24