Mem 603 Po8 Individual Assigment Sept 2019 Assesment

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

INDIVIDUAL ASSIGNMENT - ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION OBJECTIVE:

COURSE OUTCOME (CO)

PROGRAM OUTCOME (PO)

Identify ethical principles and commit to professional ethics and responsibilities and norms of engineering practice. [PO8 LO6];{A4}.

PO8 Ethics - Apply ethical principles and commit to professional ethics and responsibilities and norms of engineering practice (WK7);

ASSIGNMENT GUIDELINES 1. Select a particular Case Study as listed in Appendix 1. 2. Imagine you are safety officer, you received the information regarding the accident as listed in Appendix 1. 3. Part A- You are required to explain each step in order to carry out the accident investigation with professionally ethics, fill the suitable form and prepare the accident report. 4. Part B- Provide suggestions for preventive action, especially in term of engineering control in order to avoid similar accidents happen in the company. (supported with relevant photo/technical diagrams/drawings/ form) 5. Part C- Identify the ethical principles and professional ethics exist/ potential to happen to the case study that you have chosen. Example: construction industry – ethical issues: corruption, materials used are out of specification etc.

REPORT 1. Prepare your report with the details of all the tasks. 2. The report should include part A, B and C. 3. The explanation of accident investigation and preventive action should be supported with relevant photo/technical diagrams/drawings/ form. 4. Provide suggestions for preventive action, especially in term of engineering control in order to avoid similar accidents happen in the company. 5. Identify the ethical principles and professional ethics exist/ potential to happen to the case study that you have chosen. Example: construction industry – ethical issues: corruption, materials used are out of specification etc.

UPDATED on December 2, 2019

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

Appendix 1

DOWNLOAD: Fatal Accident Case FROMhttp://www.dosh.gov.my/index.php/en/fatal-accident-case

UPDATED on December 2, 2019

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603) LECTURER NAME

DUE DATE

SUBMISSION DATE

REMARKS

Ir. Dr. Noriah Yusoff

-on time/- late

GROUP NO No 1

Name

GENERAL GUIDELINES:

Student ID

LEVEL

POOR

Scale

1-2

Assessment Criteria

(Report)

Introduction

MARGIN AL 3-4

ACCEPTAB LE 5,6

Weight (w)

GOOD 7,8

Scale (y)

EXCELLEN T 9,10

Total= w * y

10

Content/ Diagrams/Figures/ Discussion and Conclusion Part A- Accident Investigation

40

Part B- Preventative Action

20

Part C - Identification

20

Format, Language and Organization,

10

References and citation TOTAL

100%

REMARKS: FATAL ACCIDENT CASES IN 2018 FOR GROUP EMD7M4A

UPDATED on December 2, 2019

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

RUBRIC ASSESSMENT-REPORT GENERAL GUIDELINES:

Scale Criteria

LEVEL

POOR

Scale

1-2 1-2 Poor

Topic is poorly Introduction introduced. Lack of understanding on the topic. Contents Part A-C

Research Result

Topic is poorly discussed. Lack/ absent of supporting evidence.

MARGIN AL 3-4 3,4 Margin al

ACCEPTAB LE 5,6

5,6 Acceptable

Topic is fairly introduced. Moderately understand on the topic. Fairly general research on the concept and its applications. Some supporting evidence is provided.

GOOD

EXCELLENT

7,8 7,8 Good

9,10 9-10 Excellent

Topic is well introduced.Clearly explain on the topics. Well and thorough research in the concept and its applications. Effective supporting evidence is provided. Able to make use of all relevant and available resources effectively Receptive to new ideas, critics, suggestions and able to act accordingly Show strong interest and curiosity in acquiring new knowledge and expanding it to new horizon through resource utilization. Many resources explored Sources of reference are well cited with complete explanation of tables and figures

Inadequate use of resources Not receptive to new ideas and unable Utilization of to utilize them resources Lack of interest References and curiosity in and citation acquiring new knowledge Not many resources explored Inadequate or no citation of resources

Adequate use of resources Receptive to some new ideas and partially able to act autonomously Show interest and curiosity in acquiring new knowledge and expanding it through new resources utilization Adequately cite all references

Conclusion

Unclear conclusion of the topic.

Topic is fairly concluded.

Topic is well concluded.

Writing is disorganized, unfocused to the main theme and disconnected. Not following the required format of presentation.

Writing is found to be in accordance with course requirements and have some focus on discernible theme and supporting details.

Writing is well organized and covered relevant to the course requirements and topics for discussions. Each sub-topic is clear and well structured.

Organizati Format on

Language Writing

Writing lacks clear sentences and paragraphs. Deficiencies in good grammatically skill witting.

Writing skills are somehow clear and paragraphs are well structured. Less grammar mistakes

Factor

Excellent writing skills in the use of words and prefect grammar. Sources of reference are well cited with complete explanation of tables and figures

UPDATED on December 2, 2019

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603)

APPENDIX 1 http://www.dosh.gov.my/index.php/en/fatal-accident-case 2018: FATAL ACCIDENT CASES REPORTED BY DEPARTMENT OF OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (DOSH) MALAYSIA NO

DATE

TITLE CASE

LOCATION

SUMMARY CASE

OBSERVATION

STUDENT ID

NAMA PELAJAR

1

1/04/2018

Died being hit by lorry

Construction site, Johor

A general workers being ran over by a lorry. He died on the scene

i. No SOP ii. Failure to provide a safe workplace to its staff

2016218454

ADRY BIN ABDUL RAHIM

2

1/09/2018

Died falling from height

Palm Oil Mill, Pahang

a general worker had fell from the height of 12 meter as he was repairing the roof

i) victim did not wear safety harness when working at height ii) no supervision from the employer

2017806724

AHMAD AJMAL BIN RAMLAN

3

2/09/2018

Died, exposed to Rotary's machine blade

Timber factory, Kedah

Victim, machine operators died after being slip and fall down to the bottom of the machine while cleaning was done at the top of the Rotary machine

i. No HIRARC for the activity ii. No SOP for the activity iii. Fail to provide training iv. Fail to report the accident immediately . Fail to appoint SHO

2016218526

AHMAD HAZIQ DANIAL BIN YUSAINI

4

4/10/2018

Died falling from height

Construction site, Selangor

The victim, a subcontractor worker died after falling from level 9 while installing aluminium formwork

i. No fence on opening edges. ii. Wrong usage of safety harness iii. Installing and transferring work for working platform not according to method statement

2017665756

AIDA NUR SYAFIQAH BINTI SHAARI

UPDATED on December 2, 2019

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603) 5

5/10/2018

Died being caught by bracket conveyor

Plantation, Johor

Victim, a plantation worker died after caught by bracket conveyor while doing cleaning work in the conveyor area

i. No SOP for conveyor maintenance works ii. Tiada HIRARC kerja berkaitan iii. Gagal mengadakan latihan, arahan dan maklumat iv. Gagal mengadakan tempat kerja yang selamat

2016218546

AIDIL FADHILAF BIN AWANG

6

6/09/2018

Died falling from height

Construction site, Pulau Pinang

a general worker had fell from level 6 as he was walking the scaffold's temporary ladder

i) unsafe access to the temporary ladder ii) wall opening was not properly covered

2017806526

AINA BALQIS BINTI AZRIN

7

7/06/2018

Died due to explosion

Construction site, Johor

A worker died as a result of explosion incident as he was unlocking cabinet. His body was found 35 feet from the scene

i. No SOP ii. No HIRARC

2017806412

AINUL MUSTAQIM BIN ABDUL MUTTALIB

8

7/07/2018

Died being ran over by lorry

Construction site, Sarawak

There was an accident between lorry from construction site and a car. Car driver, a civilian was died in that accident

the car found to be speedy

2017806616

AISYAH MAISARAH BINTI EPANDI

9

8/06/2018

Died falling from height

Construction site, Sabah

A subcontractor's worker died as he fallen down at the height of approximately 22 meters. He was doing formwork

i) Improper use of working platform ii) No PPE iii) Scaffold installation is not according to specification.

2017806542

ALIFF ZHARFAN BIN AZIZUL RAHIM

UPDATED on December 2, 2019

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603) 10

8/10/2018

Died being crushed by container

Transportation , Selangor

Victim, a lorry driver died after being crushed by a fell container during the container transferring process.

i. Safety pin (twist lock container) did not fit properly to tie up the container. ii. The container slid down because Road condition is not smooth and high. iii. Fail to show training records for the operator. iv. Fail to report the accident to DOSH

2016218438

AMIER DANIAL BIN NOR AZIZI

11

9/01/2018

Died falling from height

Construction site, Kuala Lumpur

A construction worker died after falling from level 3 and subsequently crushed by concrete and scaffolding

No safe working procedure and Method Statement with regards to the supervision of construction and stability support

2017806386

ASYRAF BIN ABDUL RAHIM

12

9/10/2018

Died, road accident

Cleaning Company, Kedah

Victims, a waste collection crew were killed in a road accident after the victim truck collided with tipper truck on the sidewalk.

The victim's truck collided with a tipper truck lying on the side of the road which resulted in the death of the victim and 3 other victims of the injured

2017806392

ERIK SHAH BIN LILI MURAD

13

9/10/2018

Died falling from height

Construction, Melaka

The victim, a subcontractor was killed after falling at the height of 8 meters into the sewer hole.

i. No SOP for sewerage construction ii. No SOP for rescue works in sewer hole if there is emergency. iii. No training to workers for sewerage activity iv. No valid CF for the hoisting machineries.

2017806632

EZAT QUDRAT BIN NOOR EFFENDY

UPDATED on December 2, 2019

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603) 14

10/12/2018

Died falling from height

Factory, Penang

sub-contracted worker died after falling with a forklift engine from a height of 40 feet

Forklift used several times on the day of the event to easily unload the goods using the platform as a lifting equipment.

2016229514

FARIS AFIQ BIN SALLEHUDIN

15

11/08/2018

Died falling from height

Construction site, Pahang

A construction worker died due to fell from floor 39 to 3rd floor as he was performing cleaning jobs on cantilever platform

Walls opening was not covered

2016218598

IBRAHIM DASUQI BIN SUDIN

16

11/10/2018

Died, crushed by excavator

Plantation, Selangor

IKMAL HISHAM BIN ZAINOL

11/12/2018

6 dead workers in a fire

Stor, Perak

i. No safety belt in excavator sitting seat. ii. No HIRARC and NO SOP for excavator operation The workplace was found to store items for events on the ground floor and store explosives and fireworks for the purpose of the upstart event

2017806698

17

The victim, a subcontractor worker died after fall and crushed by excavators bucket. 6 workers were killed in a fire at items storage

2017806612

MOHAMAD AFIQ BIN AHMAD

18

13/07/2018

Died falling from height

Factory, Selangor

Victim, a production supervisor has died due to falling from height

unsafe scaffold use

2017806288

MOHAMAD HAFSHAM BIN MAZLAN

19

16/07/2018

Died falling from height

Construction site, Melaka

A construction worker has died after he fell down from 7th floor. He was carried down scaffold during incident

i) no record on training for working at height ii) not wearing PPE

2016218544

MOHAMAD RAHIMAN BIN MUSTAPHA

UPDATED on December 2, 2019

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603) 20

16/12/2018

Died, electric shock

Factory, Sarawak

sub-contractor were killed when washing shoes at Washing Bay using 'water jet

i. The OM Material (SB) has disturbed the scene by removing the fuse boxes and all existing electrical wires.

2017687192

MOHAMMAD FITRI AMAR BIN MOHD NAZRI

21

17/06/2018

Died falling from height

University, Kedah

Victim was a contract worker involving with the pest control job. He was found dead due to fall from level 4

i. No SOP. ii. Tiada HIRARC. iii. Did not wear any PPE

2016218404

MUHAMAD AMIR HAIKAL BIN MOHD ZAINUDIN

22

18/09/2018

Died, crushed by tractor

Plantation, Perak

The victim, lawn tractor driver was trapped inside the tractor after the tractor overturned in a 10-feet drain

i. HIRARC need to recheck. ii. SOP need to recheck.

2016218292

MUHAMMAD ASYRAF BIN KAMIL HAMZAH

23

18/09/2018

Died, crushed by excavator

Construction, Sarawak

General worker died after the machine operate by victim crushed by overturned excavator while down the slope.

2016229324

MUHAMMAD HAZIQ BIN MOHD PAZLI

24

19/08/2018

Died being caught in an rotating machine

Quarry, Sarawak

a worker has died due to his hand being caught in a machine as he tried to remove residual using scoop shovel

i. No site registration number (construction site) ii. Fail to produce SOP iii. Fail to produce training records. iv. Fail to produce PPE records i) No SOP for maintenance activity ii) No record on training iii) no record of conducting HIRARC

2016229528

MUHAMMAD HAZIQ BIN MOHD. AWANG

UPDATED on December 2, 2019

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603) 25

19/10/2018

Died, electric shock

Jetty, Sarawak

The victim operator of sand barge, falls into the river after being hit by electric shock during the work of sucking water out of the barge using an 'electric water pump'

"i The sand barges have not been at the jetty, believed to have been out of sand dredging. ii. 'Electric water pump' and electrical connections are on board. "

2016218406

MUHAMMAD SYAFIQ SYAZWAN BIN MOHD FAIZAL

26

20/04/2018

Died falling from height

Factory, Johor

i. No safe working procedure for working at height ii. No HIRARC at work iii. No SHO and SHC

2017806798

MUHAMMAD WA'IE AZFAR BIN ISHAK

27

20/07/2018

Killed by falling bricks

Construction site, Melaka

NURDALILAH BINTI NOORDIN

20/12/2018

Died falling from height

Construction, Johor

i. No SOP for lifting works ii. No SOP for working at height Employer fails to report accident to DOSH

2017806758

28

The victim fell at a height of 10 meters when the roof supports were broken. He is passing through PVC during incident A construction workers has died after being hit by falling bricks A construction worker died after 17 days of receiving treatment at the Sultan Ismail Hospital. Victims are suspected of falling from 1st floor at construction site.

2017806814

NURHAFIZIN ZIKRY BIN MOHD NORDIN

29

21/10/2018

Died, crushed by brick wall

Construction site, Selangor

The tower crane operator died after a brick wall collapse and crushed the victim while on the way to the 7th floor 'resting area'.

i. The brick wall work was not fully assembled and there is no stiffener or support to support the brick wall

2017806646

NURUL SYAFIQAH BINTI ZABIDI

30

21/11/2018

Died falling from height

construction, Selangor

A helper at construction site falling from a height of 15 meters high when it bore iron rebates to a crane sling

i. Failure to observe SOP. ii. Existing HIRARC failures for truck operator risk for loadlifting activities

2017806838

SHARIFAH SHAHIRAH BINTI TUAN AZAM

UPDATED on December 2, 2019

FACULTY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MARA (UiTM)

INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT FORM OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH (MEM 603) 31

21/12/2018

Dies ,stuck at conveyor

Factory, Perak

A general worker died after being caught in a conveyer machine. The victims are suspected of climbing the wall of the conveyer and slip into the conveyer '

Employer fails to document a SOP for entry or maintenance work in the 'conveyer'

2017806746

SYED IKMAL HADI BIN SYED SHAHARUDDIN

32

21/12/2018

Died falling from height

Factory, Perak

Sub-contractor worker died after falling at a height of 7 meters during the work of roof replacement.

i. Employer fails to provide secure work system for related work ii. No SOP working in height iii. No supervision and supervision of the employer iv. There is no training for working at height

2017806694

SYEIKH ABDUL AZIZ BIN SYEIKH AHMAD RIDHOUDHI

UPDATED on December 2, 2019